If you sell on Amazon, you already know the Buy Box is everything. More than 80% of sales happen through it. However, what is often overlooked is just how much fulfillment performance determines whether you win or lose.
From supporting scaling brands and building businesses, I’ve seen firsthand how the operational side can make or break success on Amazon. Here are three clear reasons why fast and reliable fulfilment is the lever you need to pull:
1. Amazon Rewards Speed Above All Else
Amazon’s algorithm is designed around one thing: giving customers what they want, when they want it. That means speed.
If your fulfilment times lag behind your competitors — even by a day — you’re losing ground. Whether you’re using FBA or fulfilling orders yourself, next-day and two-day delivery are now the minimum.
In my own experience, I’ve seen the difference between a one-day dispatch and a three-day dispatch isn’t just service quality — it’s sales. If you’re not prioritising speed, you’re not really competing.
2. Reliability Builds Trust with Amazon (and Your Customers)
Fast delivery is great, but consistent delivery is what wins long term. Amazon tracks whether you meet your promises every single time. One late shipment, one “item arrived late” complaint, or one stockout can push you down the rankings.
I’ve worked with brands that treated fulfilment as a back-office task, and they quickly learned how costly that mindset is. The ones that grew fastest were the ones who treated fulfilment as a core part of their customer promise — accuracy, processes, no excuses. That reliability signals to Amazon: you can trust me with the Buy Box.
3. The Buy Box Is About Customer Experience, Not Just Price
Many sellers believe the Buy Box is solely about pricing. It’s not. Amazon is built on trust, and trust is built through customer experience.
Think about it: if one seller is 50p (or cent) cheaper but can’t deliver until next week, while another seller can have it on the customer’s doorstep tomorrow, which one do you think Amazon favours? Customers will always pick speed and reliability over a small saving.
This is one of the reasons I started ParcelPlanet. I saw brands with great products and competitive prices losing because they didn’t take fulfillment seriously. They didn’t realise that operations drive trust — and trust drives sales.
✅ The bottom line: Winning the Buy Box isn’t about being the cheapest. It’s about being the most reliable partner Amazon can put in front of its customers. Fast, accurate, and consistent fulfilment is no longer optional — it’s the standard.
If you want to win, make fulfillment your competitive edge.
About the Author
Mark Greene, CEO of ParcelPlanet, helps eCommerce brands scale by delivering fast, reliable, and customer-focused fulfillment solutions.
Comments will be approved before showing up.
